When we think about the causes of car accidents, our minds often jump to distracted driving, speeding, or impaired drivers. These are the obvious dangers—the ones we’re taught to avoid. But there’s another silent threat that rarely gets the attention it deserves: poor vehicle maintenance.
Every time you get behind the wheel, you’re trusting that your vehicle will perform safely. But worn-out brakes, bald tires, or malfunctioning lights can quickly turn a routine drive into a dangerous—and even deadly—situation. What many drivers don’t realize is that neglecting regular vehicle maintenance doesn’t just put lives at risk; it can also expose you to serious legal consequences if your negligence contributes to a crash.
In this blog, we’ll explore how vehicle neglect can lead to accidents, who may be held liable in these cases, and what you can do to stay safe and legally protected. Whether you’re a daily commuter, a business owner managing a fleet, or someone who’s been injured in a collision caused by mechanical failure, this guide will provide the legal insight and practical steps you need to understand your rights and responsibilities.
Let’s break down the risks—and how to avoid them.
Today’s vehicles are high-tech machines, but they’re not maintenance-free. Over time, brakes wear down, tires lose tread, fluids run low, and warning lights come on for a reason. Ignoring these signs can be dangerous.
According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), mechanical failures—especially brake issues—are a factor in about 2% of all crashes. That may sound small, but with millions of crashes every year, it adds up fast.
Proper maintenance isn’t just good practice—it’s your legal responsibility.
Here are some of the most frequent maintenance-related issues that personal injury and car accident lawyers see:
Brake Failure: Worn brake pads or low brake fluid can result in slower reaction times or complete brake loss.
Tire Blowouts: Bald or underinflated tires are prone to blowouts, especially at high speeds or in bad weather.
Faulty Windshield Wipers: Poor visibility during rain or snow can turn minor issues into major collisions.
Headlight/Taillight Issues: Dim or non-functioning lights reduce your visibility—and make you harder to see.
Steering or Suspension Problems: If your car veers or shakes, poor alignment or worn suspension could be to blame.
When these problems contribute to a crash, they may form the basis of a negligence claim—especially if it’s shown that the vehicle owner failed to address obvious maintenance issues.
In accidents caused by vehicle neglect, multiple parties could potentially be held responsible:
Driver or Vehicle Owner
You may be liable if you:
Ignored dashboard warning lights
Skipped scheduled inspections or repairs
Continued driving despite obvious mechanical problems
Mechanics and Repair Shops
Shops can be held accountable if:
Repairs were performed incorrectly
Known problems were missed or ignored
Commercial and Rental Vehicle Companies
Businesses like trucking or rental companies must follow strict maintenance standards. Failing to do so can make them liable if an accident occurs due to vehicle issues.
Imagine a driver on the freeway suffers a tire blowout, causing a multi-vehicle collision. An investigation reveals that the tires were dangerously worn, and the owner hadn’t replaced them in years. In this case, an auto accident attorney would argue that the driver’s neglect directly caused the crash.
Or consider a commercial truck with faulty brakes that rear-ends multiple vehicles. If inspection records show missed maintenance, a truck accident lawyer may pursue legal action against the company, not just the driver.
If you’ve been injured in a crash caused by someone else’s poorly maintained vehicle, proving negligence could significantly strengthen your case. A personal injury law firm can help you pursue:
Full Compensation for medical expenses, lost income, and emotional distress
Insurance Settlements that reflect the true cost of the accident
Lawsuits against the responsible party if insurance offers fall short
On the other hand, if you’re being accused of causing a crash due to your own lack of maintenance, you’ll need legal help to defend yourself.
Here are a few misconceptions that could hurt your case:
“I didn’t know there was a problem.”
Not knowing is not a valid defense. You’re responsible for the condition of your vehicle.
“It seemed like a minor issue.”
Minor problems can quickly escalate into major dangers. For example, a squeaky brake could signal serious wear.
“It’s the mechanic’s fault.”
While a shop may share liability, vehicle owners are still expected to monitor and follow up on repairs.
Q: Can I be held legally responsible if my car causes an accident due to poor maintenance?
A: Yes. As a vehicle owner or driver, you’re legally responsible for keeping your car in safe working condition. If worn brakes, bald tires, or another neglected issue leads to a crash, you may be considered negligent and held liable for damages.
Q: What if I didn’t know there was a maintenance issue with my car?
A: Unfortunately, “I didn’t know” is rarely a valid legal defense. You are expected to routinely inspect your vehicle, respond to warning signs (like dashboard lights), and follow the manufacturer’s maintenance schedule. Ignorance of a problem doesn’t excuse responsibility if that issue causes harm.
Q: Can a mechanic or repair shop be held liable if something they fixed goes wrong?
A: Yes—if a mechanic performed negligent or incomplete work, and that directly contributed to an accident, they may share legal responsibility. However, proving this typically requires detailed evidence, including service records and expert evaluations.
Q: What types of maintenance issues most commonly lead to accidents?
A: Some of the most common include:
Brake failure
Tire blowouts or tread separation
Steering or suspension malfunctions
Non-functioning headlights, brake lights, or turn signals
Faulty windshield wipers or defrosters reducing visibility
Q: What should I do if I’m injured in a crash caused by a poorly maintained vehicle?
A: Seek immediate medical attention, gather as much information as possible (photos, witness contacts, vehicle details), and contact a personal injury attorney. An experienced lawyer can help determine whether maintenance issues played a role in the accident and build a case for compensation.
Q: How can I prove that poor vehicle maintenance caused the crash?
A: Your attorney may:
Review maintenance records
Investigate inspection history
Examine police or crash reports
Work with mechanical experts to assess vehicle condition
If there’s evidence of neglect—like bald tires, worn-out brakes, or a known mechanical issue—it could strengthen your personal injury claim.
Q: What steps can I take to protect myself legally as a driver?
A:
Follow your car’s recommended maintenance schedule
Keep records of all repairs and inspections
Respond promptly to warning lights or unusual sounds
Use trusted mechanics
Perform regular safety checks on tires, brakes, lights, and fluids
Proactively maintaining your vehicle is not just about safety—it’s about liability protection, too.
Preventing accidents—and protecting yourself legally—starts with proactive maintenance. Here are a few simple steps:
Stick to Your Vehicle’s Maintenance Schedule
Follow the manufacturer’s recommendations in your owner’s manual.
Do Monthly Safety Checks
Check tire pressure, fluid levels, lights, and brakes regularly.
Work with Certified Mechanics
Choose reputable professionals and keep all service records.
Don’t Ignore Dashboard Warnings
Warning lights are there for a reason—address them promptly.
Documenting your maintenance history can also help you in the event of a legal dispute.
Whether you were injured by someone else’s poorly maintained vehicle or are being blamed for mechanical failure, legal help can make all the difference.
Search for experienced attorneys like:
Car crash lawyer near me
Personal injury attorney Nebraska
Auto accident attorney Omaha
Truck wreck law firm
These professionals can:
Investigate maintenance records
Gather evidence
Consult with mechanical experts
Build a solid legal strategy
At Inkelaar Law, we understand that no two accidents are the same—especially when poor vehicle maintenance is involved. Our team has years of experience handling complex injury cases across Nebraska and Florida.
We offer:
Free case evaluations
Compassionate, personalized service
A proven track record of success
Expertise in auto, motorcycle, and truck accident claims
Our Omaha car accident attorneys and Nebraska personal injury lawyers are here to support you every step of the way—from investigation to settlement or trial.
If you or a loved one has been injured in an accident involving a poorly maintained vehicle, don’t wait to protect your rights. Contact Inkelaar Law today or book an appointment to speak with our intake team. They’ll collect the details of your case and consult directly with one of our attorneys. If your case qualifies, we’ll schedule your free consultation with an attorney to discuss your legal options and next steps.
Let us help you secure the justice and compensation you deserve.
Disclaimer: The information contained in this article is for general educational purposes only. This information does not constitute legal advice, is not intended to constitute legal advice, nor should it be relied upon as legal advice for your specific factual pattern or situation. For specific legal advice, please consult with an attorney who is qualified to handle your case.
Español
